• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Angie's Cafe & Pizza - Authentic New York Slices & More in Bronx, NY

Angie’s Cafe & Pizza, nestled in the heart of the Bronx at 2559 Third Ave, serves up authentic New York-style pizza that locals rave about. Known for its generous, thin-crust slices like classic cheese, pepperoni, meat lovers, and the standout grandma slice, Angie’s delivers bold flavors with fresh ingredients and a sprinkle of oregano that elevates every bite. Beyond pizza, their menu includes wholesome sandwiches and salads, catering to diverse tastes. With fast, free delivery nearby and a warm, community-rooted atmosphere led by owner Joey and his team, Angie’s is more than a pizzeria—it’s a genuine neighborhood gem celebrated for quality and heart.

Angie's Cafe & Pizza at a glance

  • Address 2559 Third Ave, Bronx, NY 10451, United States
  • Phone +1 718-292-3606
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Breakfast , Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Angie's Cafe & Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Eduardo Blanco
5

Joey and his crew are the best. The food is great!!!

Leonora A
5

We love ordering Angie’s for work lunches a few blocks down the road. When those pizza boxes make their way to the staff lounge we know it’s going to be a delicious treat. We often place a large order for a variety of pies including classic cheese, pepperoni, meat lovers, veggie, white, and Hawaiian. Every time we open the box and see the delightful sprinkles of oregano seasoning atop the fresh cheese pies we know we are about to bite a tasty Bronx slice. Thank you Angie’s for making our work lunch breaks something to look forward to. You are more than just a NY pizza shop!

Jeffrey Otchere
5

Never heard of it before, but this spot had a good plain slice and a good margarita slice. The grandma slice by far was the best. The South Bronx is a pizza dessert but this place is legit quality

Marsha
5

Awesome pizza and definitely the BEST pizza in the area. They are genuine HUGE New York slices. I took pictures with the remote for sizing references. If you live close by the delivery is free and fast. My fave from them is definitely the pepperoni slices or pie. I frequently visit the physical location and had a chance to speak with the owner - He’s such a sweet guy. They’ve been in the area for years and watched it grow to what it is now. (Mott haven use to be really industrial) Definitely a gem in the neighborhood! They have menu options other than pizza which is a plus too.

Prem P
4

Well this is the only nice pizzeria place near my work place. And it’s a genuine pizza restaurant along side it they do have nice sandwiches and salads too.

Leslie
5

Visiting from out of state, we really wanted a genuine NY pizza. This place has GOOD pizza. The previous reviews do not lie! We got a medium pizza and it was still huge. The staff was friendly and served us as soon as we walked in.

Location

  • Angie's Cafe & Pizza
    Angie's Cafe & Pizza
    2559 Third Ave, Bronx, NY 10451, United States Hotline: +1 718-292-3606

Angie’s Cafe & Pizza stands as a true gem in the heart of the South Bronx, located at 2559 Third Ave. This pizzeria captures the spirit of New York’s legendary pizza culture with every slice they serve. From the moment you walk in or place an order, you can feel the passion Joey and his crew put into their craft.

The standout here is undoubtedly their authentic New York-style slices—large, flavorful, and generously seasoned with oregano, fresh cheese, and a perfect balance of toppings. Whether it’s the classic cheese, pepperoni, or the indulgent meat lovers, Angie’s delivers consistently satisfying pies that have locals and newcomers alike raving. The grandma slice and margherita are also highlights, offering a comforting twist on traditional flavors that stand out in the bustling Bronx pizza scene.

What adds a unique charm to Angie’s is not only the quality of the pizza but the warmth of the community surrounding the establishment. Frequent visitors talk about fast, free delivery within the neighborhood and the owner’s genuine friendliness, making each visit feel personal. Beyond pizza, the menu includes well-crafted sandwiches and fresh salads, providing satisfying choices for varied tastes.

In essence, Angie’s Cafe & Pizza is more than a pizza shop—it’s a neighborhood institution that turns everyday meals into moments of delight. For anyone seeking authentic, reliably delicious New York-style pizza paired with friendly service and a sense of place, Angie’s is a must-try in the Bronx.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards